The Stormers’ 42-21 triumph over Stade Rochelais wasn’t just another win—it was a statement. But here’s where it gets controversial: while some players shone brighter than ever, others left us questioning their consistency. Let’s dive into the player ratings from John Dobson’s squad during their Investec Champions Cup clash at Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium in Gqeberha, where brilliance and blemishes shared the spotlight.
Stormers Player Ratings vs. La Rochelle
15 Warrick Gelant (7): Gelant’s performance is a rollercoaster—you take the missteps with the magic. Today, the magic dominated. His turnover that halted La Rochelle’s momentum was pure genius, setting up Maart’s second try. And let’s not forget his try, where he plucked the ball mid-air with precision. But here’s the kicker: is his inconsistency a risk worth taking? Or is it part of what makes him so electrifying?
14 Dylan Maart (8): Patience personified, Maart waited for his moment and pounced twice. His ability to track high balls and position himself for Feinberg-Mngomezulu’s brilliance was textbook. While a few soft moments crept in, his impact was undeniable. The question remains: Can he maintain this level of performance consistently?
13 Ruhan Nel (6): Nel’s defensive structure was solid, and his turnovers were timely. However, his intercept attempt could’ve backfired—luck was on his side today. And this is the part most people miss: his 20+ metres gained with ball in hand show he’s more than just a defensive stalwart.
12 Jonathan Roche (6): Roche was the unsung hero, making strong carries and binding the backline together. No flashy moments, but his reliability is invaluable. Controversial take: Is the lack of flair a limitation, or is his role misunderstood?
11 Leolin Zas (7): Zas’ try was a masterclass in finishing, and his 40 running metres showcased his dynamism. His aerial battles and defensive work were equally impressive. But here’s the twist: Could he be doing even more with his undeniable talent?
10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu (8): The ‘Springbok in waiting’ delivered another jaw-dropping performance. Four try assists and 12 points, despite some wayward kicks, cemented his status as a generational talent. His slick pass to Maart was pure artistry. The real question: Is there anything this young prodigy can’t do? Or is he peaking too early?
9 Cobus Reinach (8): Reinach is aging like fine wine, replicating his Springbok form in the Stormers jersey. His attacking breaks were sensational, but his kicking game was equally crucial. Controversial interpretation: Is he the most underrated player on the pitch, or are we finally giving him his due?
8 Evan Roos (6): Roos’ frustration was palpable after conceding his third penalty, but his 17 metres from seven carries showed his potential. Not a game-changer today, but a solid contributor. Thought-provoking question: Is he still finding his feet, or is this his ceiling?
7 Ben-Jason Dixon (7): Dixon’s 14 tackles proved why he’s a Springbok favorite. His work ethic is unmatched, but here’s the debate: Is his old-school style sustainable in modern rugby?
6 Paul de Villiers (8): Another Man of the Match performance from de Villiers, who’s knocking on the Springbok door. His turnovers and carries were sublime, though his chalked-off try was a minor setback. Bold prediction: He’s not just a player to watch—he’s a future legend.
5 JD Schickerling (6): Schickerling’s role in de Villiers’ disallowed try was unfortunate, but his defensive strength and lineout work were commendable. The counterpoint: Is he a liability or a victim of circumstance?
4 Salmaan Moerat (5): The Stormers captain had a middling performance. Solid in lineouts and defense, but his ball-carrying was underwhelming. The burning question: Is captaincy weighing him down, or is this his new normal?
3 Neethling Fouché (6): Fouché’s scrummaging dominance was marred by his sin-binning, which La Rochelle exploited. His return saw the Stormers regain control, but the debate rages on: Was his tackle reckless or just unfortunate?
2 André-Hugo Venter (7): Venter’s lineout accuracy and well-taken try were highlights. His replacement shortly after scoring raises eyebrows. Controversial take: Was he subbed too soon, or was it the perfect tactical move?
1 Ntuthuko Mchunu (8): Mchunu’s move to Cape Town is paying dividends. His scrum dominance and three penalties won against La Rochelle’s tighthead were standout moments. The bigger picture: Is South Africa’s loosehead prop depth the real story here?
Replacements (6): The Stormers’ bench may not have been explosive, but their impact was crucial. Wandisile Simelane’s attacking moments and the front-rowers’ scrum stability were key. Marcel Theunissen’s late try sealed the deal. Final thought: Are the replacements the unsung heroes of this victory?
Now it’s your turn: Which player’s performance surprised you the most? And do you agree with the controversial takes? Let’s spark a debate in the comments!
